Atomic Structure and Isotopes: Question 9

Syllabus 2.3

Structured Extended 8 marks

A geologist analyses a magnesium-rich mineral sample in a mass spectrometer and finds three naturally occurring isotopes of magnesium present in the abundances shown in the table. Magnesium has proton number 12.

Isotope Relative abundance / %
magnesium-24 79.0
magnesium-25 10.0
magnesium-26 11.0

(a) State the number of protons and the number of neutrons in one atom of magnesium-26. [2]

(b) Calculate the relative atomic mass, ArA_r, of this magnesium sample. Give your answer to 3 significant figures. [4]

(c) Magnesium-24 and magnesium-26 have different masses. Explain, in terms of subatomic particles, why samples of pure magnesium made from only magnesium-24 atoms or only magnesium-26 atoms would react identically with dilute hydrochloric acid. [2]

Show worked solution Hide worked solution

Worked solution

Part (a): Protons and neutrons in magnesium-26

The proton number of magnesium is 1212, so every magnesium atom has 1212 protons, regardless of isotope.

For magnesium-26, the nucleon (mass) number is 2626, so:

neutrons=2612=14\text{neutrons} = 26 - 12 = 14

Part (b): Relative atomic mass from three isotopic abundances

The relative atomic mass is a weighted mean of the isotopes’ mass numbers, weighted by their percentage abundance:

Ar=(mass1×abundance1)+(mass2×abundance2)+(mass3×abundance3)100A_r = \frac{(\text{mass}_1 \times \text{abundance}_1) + (\text{mass}_2 \times \text{abundance}_2) + (\text{mass}_3 \times \text{abundance}_3)}{100}

Substituting the values for magnesium:

Ar=(24×79.0)+(25×10.0)+(26×11.0)100=1896+250+286100=2432100=24.32A_r = \frac{(24 \times 79.0) + (25 \times 10.0) + (26 \times 11.0)}{100} = \frac{1896 + 250 + 286}{100} = \frac{2432}{100} = 24.32

Giving the answer to 3 significant figures:

Ar=24.3A_r = 24.3

Part (c): Why the isotopes react identically

Magnesium-24 and magnesium-26 both have proton number 1212, so a neutral atom of each isotope has 1212 electrons, arranged in the same electronic configuration, 2,8,22,8,2. The extra 22 neutrons in magnesium-26’s nucleus add mass but do not change the number or arrangement of electrons.

Because chemical reactions (such as reacting with dilute hydrochloric acid) depend on the arrangement of electrons, particularly in the outer shell, and not on the number of neutrons, samples made from either isotope alone would react in exactly the same way. Even though the magnesium-26 sample would have a slightly greater mass overall.

Final answers

  • (a) Protons =12= 12, neutrons =14= 14.
  • (b) Ar=24.3A_r = \boxed{24.3} (3 s.f.).
  • (c) Both isotopes have 12 electrons in identical electronic configuration, so they have identical chemical reactivity.