Economic Systems and Market Failure: Question 2
Syllabus 2.8, 2.9, 2.10
The coastal fishing industry of Velmora, a small island nation, operates almost entirely through free-market allocation. Fishing crews decide independently what species to catch, how much to land each day and what price to charge, based on the prices buyers are willing to pay at the dockside auction. There is very little government regulation of the industry.
(a) Define a market economic system. [2]
(b) Explain one advantage of allocating resources in Velmora's fishing industry through a market economic system. [2]
(c) Explain one disadvantage of allocating resources in Velmora's fishing industry through a market economic system. [2]
Show worked solution Hide worked solution
Worked solution
Part (a): Defining a market economic system
A market economic system is one in which the basic questions of what to produce, how to produce it, and who receives it are answered mainly through the price mechanism, prices and profit acting as signals in response to the independent decisions of buyers and sellers, with the government playing very little role in allocating resources.
Part (b): One advantage of the market system in Velmora’s fishing industry
Because prices at the dockside auction adjust quickly to demand and supply, crews are automatically guided toward catching more of whatever species buyers currently value most, and less of species that are in low demand. No planning authority needs to instruct them. The price signal does this on its own, so resources (in this case, fishing effort) tend to flow to where they are most valued. This also rewards crews who work efficiently or land better-quality catches with higher profit, giving a direct incentive for effort and innovation.
Part (c): One disadvantage of the market system in Velmora’s fishing industry
The fishing grounds are shared: no single crew owns them or bears the full cost of depleting them. Each crew simply responds to the price it can get for what it lands today, without needing to consider the effect its catch has on the total fish population available to everyone in the future. With very little government regulation, there is nothing built into the market price to stop crews from catching more than the fish stock can replace, so the resource risks being overused, a disadvantage that arises precisely because the market system leaves resource allocation to individual price-driven decisions rather than to any collective plan.
Final answers
- (a) A market economic system allocates resources mainly through the price mechanism, with minimal government involvement.
- (b) Advantage: prices adjust quickly to demand and supply, directing crews’ effort efficiently and rewarding effort with profit.
- (c) Disadvantage: with no owner of the shared fishing grounds and little regulation, the market system does not prevent overfishing.