Comprehension: Explicit and Implicit Meaning: Question 10
Syllabus R1, R2
Read the following passage, then answer the question.
By the time the second guy rope had worked itself loose for the third time, the tent had taken on the appearance of a large green animal attempting, without much success, to lie down. Dad stood back, hands on hips, surveying the structure with the satisfied air of a man inspecting a job well done.
"Perfectly under control," he announced, to no one in particular, as one corner of the groundsheet flapped up in the wind and deposited a small drift of leaves across the sleeping bags inside. Beside him, the instructions booklet lay open and ignored on the grass, its diagrams facedown, exactly where he had thrown it forty minutes earlier after declaring that he "didn't need a manual to put up a tent."
Mum, watching from the folding chair she had set up the moment they arrived, asked mildly whether "under control" meant the tent was actually meant to lean at that particular angle, or whether that was a design feature she hadn't previously encountered. Dad said that it was, in fact, "a ventilation solution," and went to find the mallet he had somehow already lost.
Which of the following best explains the humour created by Dad's description of the tent's lean as "a ventilation solution"?
Show worked solution Hide worked solution
Worked solution
Why C is correct
The humour depends on the reader seeing what Dad will not admit: the tent is visibly failing, described as “a large green animal attempting, without much success, to lie down,” yet Dad insists it is “perfectly under control” and reframes an obvious flaw as a deliberate “design feature.” His confident, almost technical phrase (“a ventilation solution”) sits in stark contrast to the ignored instructions booklet and the mallet he has already lost, both of which reveal genuine incompetence rather than intention. The comedy comes from this gap between his composed, authoritative language and the chaotic reality Mum, and the reader, can plainly see, which is option C.
Why the other options are wrong
- A (genuinely proud/on purpose) ignores the strong visual evidence that the lean is a fault, not a feature.
- B (a shared joke) mistakes irony the reader can see for a joke the characters are consciously making together; Mum’s question is gently sceptical, not amused agreement.
- D (doesn’t understand the phrase) misses that the phrase is a deliberate excuse invented on the spot, not a genuine error of vocabulary.