Space Physics: Question 5

Syllabus 6.2.2

Multiple choice Core 1 mark

A star much more massive than the Sun has just used up all of the hydrogen fuel in its core, ending its time as a stable (main-sequence) star.

Which of the following gives the correct sequence of stages this massive star will go through next, ending with a compact remnant left behind?

Choose an answer to check it, then compare with the worked solution below.

Show worked solution Hide worked solution

Worked solution

Step 1: Identify which fate applies to a massive star

Once a star runs out of hydrogen fuel in its core, what happens next depends on the star’s mass:

  • A star with a mass similar to the Sun expands into a red giant, then forms a planetary nebula with a white dwarf at its centre.
  • A star much more massive than the Sun instead expands into a red supergiant.

Since this question describes a star much more massive than the Sun, the red giant / white dwarf pathway does not apply here.

Step 2: Follow the massive star’s sequence of stages

For a massive star, the correct sequence after it leaves the main sequence is:

red supergiantsupernovaneutron star or black hole\text{red supergiant} \rightarrow \text{supernova} \rightarrow \text{neutron star or black hole}

The star first swells into a red supergiant. When its core can no longer support the star, it collapses suddenly and explodes as a supernova, blasting most of the star’s material into space as a nebula containing hydrogen and heavier elements. Left behind at the centre is an extremely dense remnant. A neutron star, or, if the original star was massive enough, a black hole.

Why the other options are wrong

OptionWhat it describesWhy it’s wrong
ARed giant → white dwarf → planetary nebulaThis is the fate of a lower-mass star like the Sun, not a much more massive star, and the white dwarf and planetary nebula stages are also given in the wrong order
CSupernova → red supergiant → white dwarfThe order is reversed. The star must expand into a red supergiant before it explodes as a supernova, not after; a white dwarf is also not the remnant of a supernova
DPlanetary nebula → red supergiant → neutron star or black holeA planetary nebula is produced by a lower-mass star’s red giant, not by a massive star, and it would not occur before the red supergiant stage

Final answers

  • The massive star’s sequence is red supergiant → supernova → neutron star or black hole, option B