Nuclear Physics: Question 4

Syllabus 23.1

Structured A2 8 marks

In an experimental fusion reactor, deuterium and tritium nuclei fuse according to the equation: 12H+13H24He+01n^2_1\text{H}+\,^3_1\text{H}\rightarrow\,^4_2\text{He}+\,^1_0\text{n}

The nuclear masses involved are m(12H)=2.013553 um(^2_1\text{H})=2.013553\text{ u}, m(13H)=3.015500 um(^3_1\text{H})=3.015500\text{ u}, m(24He)=4.001506 um(^4_2\text{He})=4.001506\text{ u} and m(01n)=1.008665 um(^1_0\text{n})=1.008665\text{ u}.

Take 1 u=1.66×1027 kg=931.5 MeV1\text{ u}=1.66\times10^{-27}\text{ kg}=931.5\text{ MeV} and c=3.00×108 m s1c=3.00\times10^8\text{ m s}^{-1}.

(a) With reference to the graph of binding energy per nucleon against nucleon number, explain why this fusion reaction releases energy. [2]

(b) Calculate the total mass before the reaction and the total mass after the reaction, and hence find the mass defect Δm\Delta m for this reaction, in u. [2]

(c) Calculate the energy released in this fusion reaction, in MeV. [2]

(d) Show that this energy is equivalent to about 2.82×1012 J2.82\times10^{-12}\text{ J}. [2]

Show worked solution Hide worked solution

Worked solution

Part (a): Why fusion releases energy

The graph of binding energy per nucleon against nucleon number rises steeply for light nuclei, peaking around iron before falling slowly for heavy nuclei. Deuterium and tritium, both very light nuclides, sit low on the left-hand, steeply-rising part of this curve, so each of their nucleons is relatively weakly bound.

Helium-4 lies much closer to the peak of the curve, so each of its nucleons is much more strongly bound. When deuterium and tritium fuse into helium-4 (plus a neutron), the nucleons end up more tightly bound overall. This increase in total binding energy corresponds, by E=c2ΔmE=c^2\Delta m, to a decrease in total mass. The “missing” mass is released as the kinetic energy of the helium nucleus and the neutron.

Part (b): Mass defect

Total mass of the reactants (deuterium ++ tritium): mbefore=2.013553+3.015500=5.029053 um_{before}=2.013553+3.015500=5.029053\text{ u}

Total mass of the products (helium-4 ++ neutron): mafter=4.001506+1.008665=5.010171 um_{after}=4.001506+1.008665=5.010171\text{ u}

Mass defect: Δm=mbeforemafter=5.0290535.010171=0.018882 u\Delta m=m_{before}-m_{after}=5.029053-5.010171=0.018882\text{ u}

Recompute as a check, combining differently: (2.0135531.008665)+(3.0155004.001506)=1.004888+(0.986006)=0.018882 u(2.013553-1.008665)+(3.015500-4.001506)=1.004888+(-0.986006)=0.018882\text{ u}, the same result.

Δm=0.0189 u (3 s.f.)\Delta m=\boxed{0.0189}\text{ u (3 s.f.)}

Part (c): Energy released, in MeV

Using the given conversion 1 u=931.5 MeV1\text{ u}=931.5\text{ MeV} directly on the mass defect from (b): E=Δm×931.5=0.018882×931.5E=\Delta m\times931.5=0.018882\times931.5

E=0.018882×900+0.018882×31.5=16.99+0.595=17.59 MeVE=0.018882\times900+0.018882\times31.5=16.99+0.595=17.59\text{ MeV}

Recompute as a check by multiplying directly: 0.0189×931.5=17.6 MeV0.0189\times931.5=17.6\text{ MeV}, consistent with the split-sum method.

E=17.6 MeV (3 s.f.)E=\boxed{17.6}\text{ MeV (3 s.f.)}

Part (d): Show that this is about 2.82 × 10⁻¹² J

Convert the mass defect to kilograms using 1 u=1.66×1027 kg1\text{ u}=1.66\times10^{-27}\text{ kg}: Δm=0.018882×1.66×1027=3.134×1029 kg\Delta m=0.018882\times1.66\times10^{-27}=3.134\times10^{-29}\text{ kg}

Apply E=c2ΔmE=c^2\Delta m: E=(3.00×108)2×3.134×1029=9.00×1016×3.134×1029E=(3.00\times10^8)^2\times3.134\times10^{-29}=9.00\times10^{16}\times3.134\times10^{-29}

E=2.821×1012 JE=2.821\times10^{-12}\text{ J}

Recompute as a check, keeping powers of ten separate: 9.00×3.134=28.219.00\times3.134=28.21, and 1016×1029=101310^{16}\times10^{-29}=10^{-13}, giving E=28.21×1013=2.821×1012 JE=28.21\times10^{-13}=2.821\times10^{-12}\text{ J}, consistent with the value above, confirming E2.82×1012 JE\approx2.82\times10^{-12}\text{ J} as required to show.

Final answers

  • (a) Fusion moves the nucleons from a low binding energy per nucleon (deuterium, tritium) to a higher binding energy per nucleon (helium-4, near the peak of the curve); the increase in binding energy is released as kinetic energy of the products
  • (b) Δm=0.0189 u\Delta m=\boxed{0.0189}\text{ u}
  • (c) E=17.6 MeVE=\boxed{17.6}\text{ MeV}
  • (d) E2.82×1012 JE\approx\boxed{2.82\times10^{-12}}\text{ J}