Motion and Motion Graphs: Question 9

Syllabus 1.2

Structured Extended 10 marks

A train travels between two stations in a straight line. Its distance from the first station is recorded every so often, and the distance-time graph between each pair of readings is a straight line:

Time, tt / s 00 2020 5050 7070 9090
Distance, ss / m 00 400400 400400 800800 10001000

(a) Calculate the train's speed during the first section of the journey, from t=0t = 0 to t=20 st = 20\text{ s}. [2]

(b) State which section of the journey shows the train at rest, and explain how you can tell this from the table. [2]

(c) Calculate the train's speed during the section from t=50 st = 50\text{ s} to t=70 st = 70\text{ s}, and its speed during the section from t=70 st = 70\text{ s} to t=90 st = 90\text{ s}. [3]

(d) The train is approaching the second station at the end of the journey. State whether the train is speeding up or slowing down between the section in (c) covering t=50 st = 50\text{ s} to t=70 st = 70\text{ s} and the section covering t=70 st = 70\text{ s} to t=90 st = 90\text{ s}, and explain your answer. [1]

(e) Calculate the train's average speed for the whole 90 s90\text{ s} journey shown in the table. [2]

Show worked solution Hide worked solution

Worked solution

Part (a): Speed during the first section

Speed is found from the change in distance divided by the change in time, v=ΔsΔtv = \dfrac{\Delta s}{\Delta t}. Between t=0t = 0 and t=20 st = 20\text{ s}:

Δs=400 m0 m=400 m,Δt=20 s0 s=20 s\Delta s = 400\text{ m} - 0\text{ m} = 400\text{ m}, \qquad \Delta t = 20\text{ s} - 0\text{ s} = 20\text{ s}

v=400 m20 s=20 m/sv = \frac{400\text{ m}}{20\text{ s}} = 20\text{ m/s}

Part (b): Identifying the section at rest

Comparing consecutive readings in the table, the distance is 400 m400\text{ m} at both t=20 st = 20\text{ s} and t=50 st = 50\text{ s}. It has not changed over this 30 s30\text{ s} interval. Since speed is the change in distance divided by the change in time, and the change in distance here is zero, the train’s speed during this section is zero: the train is at rest from t=20 st = 20\text{ s} to t=50 st = 50\text{ s}.

Part (c): Speed during the next two sections

From t=50 st = 50\text{ s} to t=70 st = 70\text{ s}:

Δs=800 m400 m=400 m,Δt=70 s50 s=20 s\Delta s = 800\text{ m} - 400\text{ m} = 400\text{ m}, \qquad \Delta t = 70\text{ s} - 50\text{ s} = 20\text{ s}

v=400 m20 s=20 m/sv = \frac{400\text{ m}}{20\text{ s}} = 20\text{ m/s}

From t=70 st = 70\text{ s} to t=90 st = 90\text{ s}:

Δs=1000 m800 m=200 m,Δt=90 s70 s=20 s\Delta s = 1000\text{ m} - 800\text{ m} = 200\text{ m}, \qquad \Delta t = 90\text{ s} - 70\text{ s} = 20\text{ s}

v=200 m20 s=10 m/sv = \frac{200\text{ m}}{20\text{ s}} = 10\text{ m/s}

Part (d): Speeding up or slowing down

The train’s speed falls from 20 m/s20\text{ m/s} (between t=50 st = 50\text{ s} and t=70 st = 70\text{ s}) to 10 m/s10\text{ m/s} (between t=70 st = 70\text{ s} and t=90 st = 90\text{ s}). Since its speed is decreasing, the train is slowing down (decelerating). This is consistent with it approaching and preparing to stop at the second station.

Part (e): Average speed for the whole journey

Average speed uses the total distance travelled and the total time taken, not the individual section speeds:

total distance=1000 m0 m=1000 m,total time=90 s0 s=90 s\text{total distance} = 1000\text{ m} - 0\text{ m} = 1000\text{ m}, \qquad \text{total time} = 90\text{ s} - 0\text{ s} = 90\text{ s}

average speed=1000 m90 s=11.111... m/s11.1 m/s\text{average speed} = \frac{1000\text{ m}}{90\text{ s}} = 11.111...\text{ m/s} \approx 11.1\text{ m/s}

Final answers

  • (a) Speed from t=0t = 0 to t=20 st = 20\text{ s} == 20 m/s20\text{ m/s}
  • (b) The train is at rest between t=20 st = 20\text{ s} and t=50 st = 50\text{ s}
  • (c) Speed from t=50 st = 50\text{ s} to t=70 st = 70\text{ s} == 20 m/s20\text{ m/s}; speed from t=70 st = 70\text{ s} to t=90 st = 90\text{ s} == 10 m/s10\text{ m/s}
  • (d) The train is slowing down (decelerating) as it nears the second station
  • (e) Average speed for the whole 90 s90\text{ s} journey == 11.1 m/s11.1\text{ m/s}