Fiscal, Monetary and Supply-Side Policy: Economics 9708 (Cambridge International AS & A Level)
Syllabus 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, 5.4 · Strand 5 Government Macroeconomic Intervention
- Questions
- 10
- Total marks
- 81
- Tier mix
- 10 Core
0 of 10 questions completed
Syllabus coverage
- 5.1 3 questions completed
- 5.2 7 questions completed
- 5.3 3 questions completed
- 5.4 3 questions completed
Governments pursue macroeconomic objectives (price stability, low unemployment and economic growth) with three broad instruments. Fiscal policy works through government spending and taxation: a budget deficit (spending exceeds tax revenue) is typically expansionary and a budget surplus contractionary, and taxes themselves may be progressive, regressive or proportional depending on how the average rate changes with income. Monetary policy works through interest rates, the money supply and credit conditions, usually set by a central bank.
Both fiscal and monetary policy are analysed with the AD/AS model: expansionary policy shifts AD to the right to raise output and employment (at some risk to the price level), while contractionary policy shifts AD left to cool an overheating economy. Supply-side policy takes a different approach, aiming to shift long-run aggregate supply (LRAS) itself (through measures such as training, infrastructure investment and support for technological improvement) so the economy can produce more without generating extra inflationary pressure. Each policy has different speeds, side effects and political constraints, which is why real governments typically combine them.
The exam-style problems below are original, with full worked solutions.
Question 1
The government of Kelbrona wants to bring down persistently high inflation. It raises the average rate of income tax and cuts its own spending on public infrastructure projects, while leaving interest rates and the money supply unchanged.
Which term best describes this combination of policy actions?
Question 2
Bellara's government levies income tax according to the following schedule of marginal tax rates. Each rate applies only to the portion of a person's income that falls within that band.
| Band of taxable income | Marginal tax rate |
|---|---|
| $0 – $20,000 | 10% |
| $20,001 – $50,000 | 20% |
| Above $50,000 | 30% |
(a) Aiden has a taxable income of $40,000 per year. Calculate the total tax Aiden pays and Aiden's average rate of tax (ART). [3]
(b) Priya has a taxable income of $80,000 per year. Calculate the total tax Priya pays and Priya's average rate of tax (ART), and state the marginal rate of tax (MRT) that applies to the last dollar Priya earns. [3]
(c) Using your answers to (a) and (b), state and explain whether Bellara's income tax schedule is progressive, proportional or regressive. [2]
(d) Explain one reason, other than simply raising revenue, why a government might choose a progressive income tax of this kind rather than a proportional tax. [2]
Question 3
The table below shows the government of Corvane's revenue and spending over two consecutive fiscal years (all figures in $ billion).
| Year | Government revenue | Government current spending | Government capital spending |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 540 | 460 | 115 |
| Year 2 | 560 | 430 | 115 |
(a) For each year, calculate Corvane's budget balance (government revenue minus total government spending) and state whether the government ran a budget deficit or a budget surplus in that year. [4]
(b) Using AD/AS analysis, explain why the change in Corvane's fiscal position between Year 1 and Year 2 represents a contractionary fiscal policy stance, and state the likely effect of this stance on the equilibrium price level and the equilibrium level of real output, holding aggregate supply constant. [4]
(c) Explain the significance of Year 1's budget position for Corvane's national debt. [3]
Question 4
Nordevik's economy is experiencing rising inflation. In response, Nordevik's central bank raises its policy interest rate from to , while the government leaves its own spending and taxation unchanged.
(a) Explain how this rise in Nordevik's central bank interest rate is likely to be transmitted through to a fall in Aggregate Demand (AD). [3]
(b) Using AD/AS analysis, described in words, explain the likely effect of this contractionary monetary policy on Nordevik's equilibrium price level and equilibrium level of real output, holding aggregate supply constant. [3]
(c) "Contractionary monetary policy is always a faster and more reliable way than contractionary fiscal policy to bring down inflation." Discuss the extent to which you agree with this statement. [6]
Question 5
Amberlyn's government announces a major, sustained increase in spending on vocational training for workers and on new transport infrastructure (roads and ports), explicitly aimed at raising the economy's long-run productive capacity.
(a) Explain what is meant by supply-side policy, and identify two supply-side policy tools used by Amberlyn's government in this scenario. [3]
(b) Using AD/AS analysis, described in words, explain how a successful supply-side policy of this kind is expected to affect Amberlyn's long-run aggregate supply (LRAS) curve, equilibrium price level and equilibrium level of real output, and contrast this with a demand-side policy. Such as a rise in government spending (G) that shifts AD but is not accompanied by any increase in productive capacity. [5]
(c) Discuss one limitation of relying on supply-side policy, such as training and infrastructure investment, to raise Amberlyn's productive capacity. [4]
Question 6
Thornwick's government funds local road maintenance with a fixed household charge of $300 per year, charged equally to every household regardless of income. The Chen household earns $15,000 a year and the Osei household earns $60,000 a year; both households pay the same $300 charge.
Which term best describes how this charge behaves as household income rises, and how should it be classified?
Question 7
Silverport's government levies a fixed excise duty of $0.80 per litre on petrol, added to the pump price. Marco earns $16,000 a year and buys 1,000 litres of petrol during the year. Elena earns $64,000 a year and also buys 1,000 litres of petrol during the year.
(a) Calculate the total excise duty paid by Marco and by Elena, and calculate each driver's average rate of this tax as a percentage of their income. [4]
(b) State and explain whether Silverport's petrol excise duty is progressive, proportional or regressive with respect to income, using your answers to part (a). [2]
(c) Explain why a fixed-rate indirect tax of this kind, charged at the same $0.80 per litre to every driver, tends to be regressive with respect to income even though everyone pays the identical rate per litre purchased. [3]
Question 8
Halveston's economy is in recession, with falling real GDP and rising unemployment, and the central bank's policy interest rate is already close to zero. The central bank of Halveston therefore begins a programme of quantitative easing (QE), creating new money to buy government bonds from commercial banks and other financial institutions.
(a) Explain how this programme of quantitative easing is intended to increase the amount of money circulating in Halveston's economy and encourage commercial banks to lend more to households and firms. [3]
(b) Using AD/AS analysis, described in words, explain the likely effect of a successful expansionary monetary policy of this kind on Halveston's equilibrium price level and equilibrium level of real output, and explain why, given that Halveston's economy is in recession with substantial spare capacity, the effect is likely to fall mostly on real output rather than the price level. [4]
(c) Discuss the extent to which quantitative easing might fail to raise Halveston's Aggregate Demand by as much as the central bank intends. [5]
Question 9
Vantoria's economy has entered a downturn: real GDP has fallen and cyclical unemployment has risen sharply, while the country's long-run productive capacity is unaffected. Vantoria's government is considering three possible responses:
(i) a temporary, debt-financed increase in public spending on unemployment benefits and public-sector wages; (ii) instructing the (independent) central bank to cut its policy interest rate; (iii) a long-term programme of deregulation, removing licensing requirements that currently make it slow and costly to open a new small business, in order to encourage entrepreneurship.
(a) Classify each of options (i), (ii) and (iii) as fiscal, monetary or supply-side policy. [3]
(b) Using AD/AS analysis, explain why options (i) and (ii) are likely to reduce Vantoria's cyclical unemployment more quickly than option (iii). [4]
(c) Discuss the extent to which option (iii) might nonetheless offer a more effective long-term solution to Vantoria's unemployment than either option (i) or option (ii). [5]
Question 10
Which of the following is the best example of a supply-side fiscal policy measure, rather than a purely demand-side fiscal policy measure?